Someone in your life has a reef tank. They talk about alkalinity at dinner, they check an app before bed, and they once left a party early because the power went out at home. You want to get them something they will use, and you are not sure what a refractometer is. This list is from a store that sells and ships these animals every week, so it includes the part other gift guides leave out: how to give something alive without it arriving dead or unwanted.
The one rule
Never send a live animal as a surprise. A coral, a fish or a cleanup crew needs a tank that is ready for it and a person who is home the day it lands. Everything on this list that is not alive can be a surprise. Everything that is alive should be planned with the person who will keep it.
Three things to find out first
You can get these in one casual conversation, or from the person who lives with them.
- How big is the tank, in gallons? Almost every piece of equipment and every cleanup crew is sized by tank volume.
- What lives in it? Fish only, soft corals, or stony corals such as acropora. Stony coral keepers test more often and care more about precise tools.
- What have they been complaining about? Algae, a salinity reading they do not trust, a cleanup crew that keeps dwindling. The complaint is usually the gift.
Small gifts that get used every week
These are safe surprises. Nobody who keeps a reef has too many of them.
- VCA 12″ Never-Rust Aquarium Tweezers. All-plastic tweezers for placing frags and grabbing things in the tank without putting a hand in. They float if dropped. A longer 19″ version suits deeper tanks.
- Two Little Fishies CorAffix Gel. Thick gel glue for attaching frags to plugs and rock.
- Two Little Fishies ReVive Coral Cleaner. A coral dip for cleaning new corals before they go in the tank. Useful for anyone who buys corals.
- Two Little Fishies MagFox. A magnetic brush for cleaning algae out of pump intakes and tight spaces that a glass magnet cannot reach.
- Two Little Fishies sticker, for the stocking.
Testing gear, for the one who worries about numbers
Reef tanks run on test results. A better test is one of the few gifts that changes how someone keeps their tank.
- Milwaukee MA887 Digital Salinity Refractometer. Reads salinity from a few drops of tank water in a couple of seconds, with temperature compensation. A good pick for anyone still squinting at a hydrometer or an analog refractometer.
- Red Sea Algae Control Pro Multi Test Kit. Nitrate and low-range phosphate in one kit, the two numbers behind most algae trouble.
- Hanna Phosphate Ultra Low Range Checker. A pocket colorimeter that reads phosphate as a number instead of a color match. It matters most in stony coral tanks, where phosphate is kept low.
- Triton ICP-OES Water Test. A mail-in lab test. They send a water sample, and the lab reports 45 parameters with dosing recommendations. A good gift for someone who has everything, because it is a test they would not usually buy for themselves.
Something to read
The Coral Reef Aquarium, Volume 2 by Julian Sprung and J. Charles Delbeek is a standard reference on keeping reef aquariums. Books are an easy surprise, because it does not matter what is in their tank.
For someone who is just starting
If the person is setting up their first saltwater tank, the useful gifts are the boring ones: the supplements and test kits they will need in the first few months. The Waterbox Saltwater Starter Bundle covers the essential supplements, and the Waterbox Saltwater Complete Bundle adds test kits. If you are thinking about giving the tank itself, read our guide to what a saltwater aquarium costs first, because the tank is only part of it.
Gifting live coral safely
Live coral can be a wonderful gift. It can also be a box that sits on a cold porch for six hours. Everything below comes from how we ship every order, and it applies to any live animal you send as a gift.
- The tank has to be ready. Ask the person, or someone who knows the tank, before you order. A coral that does not suit their light, flow or water is not a gift.
- Never a surprise box. Plan the delivery with the person who will receive it. Live animals ship UPS Next Day Air on Tuesdays and Wednesdays only, so nothing sits in a facility over a weekend.
- Someone has to be home. Overnight boxes left on a doorstep in the sun or the cold are the most common cause of loss. The person should plan to receive the box, or arrange a hold at their UPS facility.
- Weather can move the date. If conditions at either end put the animals at risk, we hold the box and get in touch. A week’s delay beats a dead coral, so build a little slack into a holiday plan.
- Tell them about the sealed-bag photo. Our live arrival guarantee depends on one thing: a clear photo or video of the animal in the sealed, unopened bag, sent within 4 hours of the UPS delivery scan, with the order number. The recipient needs to know that before they open the box, or a claim cannot be honored.
- Know what the guarantee covers. It covers the animal arriving alive. Once it is acclimated into their tank, its health depends on their water, light and flow.
- Expect a slow start. Most corals do not open on day one. A coral that arrives closed is usually showing normal shipping stress, not dying. Tell them to give it a few days in stable water.
- Check where they live. We ship to the continental United States only, not to Alaska or Hawaii.
- Ask before you buy. All sales on live animals are final, because a shipped coral cannot go back into our systems. Call or email us with the tank details and we will tell you honestly what fits, including when the answer is not that coral.
Our shipping and live arrival guarantee page has the full details.
A cleanup crew as a gift
A cleanup crew is the most practical live gift there is, because nearly every reef tank keeps one. Our Complete Clean Up Crew, Florida Keys, by Tank Size is packed by tank size, so the one fact you need is the number of gallons. The animals are collected here in the Florida Keys.
The same rules apply as for coral: plan the delivery with them, and make sure someone is home. One more caution from the listing: a tank that has just cycled cannot feed a full crew. If their tank is under two months old, order the size below theirs. If you are not sure what size to get, our cleanup crew calculator works it out from the tank size and what the algae is doing.
If they are visiting Key West
If the reefer in your life is coming to Key West, the best gift may be the visit. At our shop they can pick the actual coral in person, under our lights, and we hold it in our systems and ship it home on a Tuesday or Wednesday that suits their travel. Nothing has to ride in a suitcase. See choose your coral in Key West, we ship it home, and our Visit Us page for directions and hours.
FAQ
Can you give coral as a gift?
Yes, if the person’s tank is ready for it and they know it is coming. Plan the delivery date with them, make sure someone is home, and tell them to photograph the sealed bag before opening it.
Can I send a coral or fish as a surprise?
We advise against it. A surprise box can sit on a doorstep, and the animal may not suit the tank. Give something that is not alive as the surprise, and plan the live part together.
What do you get a reefer who has everything?
A lab water test such as the Triton ICP-OES test, a good reference book, or a fresh cleanup crew sized to their tank. Most reefers will not buy those for themselves.
What is a good gift for someone starting a saltwater tank?
Supplements, test kits and a refractometer. The first few months of a new tank are about testing and patience, not livestock.
What days do you ship live animals?
Tuesdays and Wednesdays, UPS Next Day Air, so nothing sits in a facility over a weekend.
Do you ship to Alaska or Hawaii?
No. We ship to the continental United States only.
Not sure what to get?
Tell us the tank size and what is in it, and we will suggest something that fits. Call (305) 850-9949 or email info@theunderwatergardener.com. You can also browse our testing gear and cleanup crew.
The Underwater Gardener is a reef aquarium store in Key West, Florida. Livestock ships UPS Next Day Air on Tuesdays and Wednesdays.
Corals in stock right now
Photographed in Key West, in stock today. Fill your box: up to 4 spots ship for one shipping charge. A frag takes 1 spot and a colony takes 2. Browse corals under $100 or beginner corals to fill one.



Comments (0)